The 1986 Midterms: Reagan Still Popular, Republicans Not So Much

Forty years ago another two term Republican president faced a midterm election, and the results were not good for the Republicans in the Senate, with them losing a net of eight seats and thus the Senate, although the House results were far less punishing than 2026. This result wasn’t as bad for Republicans First, the Democratic Party of the time was less liberal than it is now. However, the results nonetheless were good enough for Democrats for retiring Speaker of the House Tip O’Neill (D-Mass.) to declare, “If there was a Reagan Revolution, it’s over” (Ryan-Hume). President Reagan himself had campaigned across the country in the hopes that the 1986 election would bear resemblance to the 1980 election, but it wasn’t so. However, unlike today, voters were not concerned about the economy, as in 1986 the economy was experiencing its third straight year of growth and Reagan himself was still popular with voters, polling at 66% unlike Trump today whose approval rating entering Election Day was around 38-39%. The drag on the Republican Party was the Republican brand being less popular than the Democratic brand rather than Reagan himself.

Sen. George Mitchell (D-Me.), chairman of the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee for 1986 and majority leader from 1989 to 1995.

Since Democrats already had the House, the Democrats only gained five seats, but credit nonetheless goes to Representative Tony Coelho (D-Calif.), chairman of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, throughout the 1980s for maintaining a Democratic majority:

In Colorado, Republican Michael Strang of the 3rd district lost reelection to Democrat Ben Nighthorse Campbell, who would switch to the GOP as a senator in 1995.

In Hawaii, Democrats lost the 1st district when Republican Pat Saiki won the district after Neil Abercrombie left office.

In Indiana, the retirement of Republican Bud Hillis in the 5th district yielded the election of Democrat Jim Jontz. Incidentally, the one district Republicans held that they lost in Indiana this year was the 5th.

In Iowa, there was a mixed result. The retirement of Republican T. Cooper Evans in the 3rd district yielded the election of Democrat David Nagle while the retirement of Democrat Berkley Bedell in the 6th district yielded the election of Republican actor Fred Grandy.

In Louisiana, the retirement of Catherine Long, the widow of the late Gillis Long in the 8th district, yielded the election of Republican Clyde Holloway.

In Maine, Republican John McKernan of the 1st district retired to run for governor, yielding the election of Democrat Joseph Brennan.

In Maryland, the retirement of Republican Marjorie Holt of the 4th district resulted in the election of Democrat Tom McMillen, but the retirement of Democrat Michael Barnes in the 8th district yielded the election of Republican Connie Morella.

In Mississippi, Republican Webb Franklin of the 2nd district lost reelection to Democrat Mike Espy, the first black person elected to Congress from Mississippi since Reconstruction. That district has not again elected a Republican.

In Missouri, Democrat Robert Young of the 2nd district lost reelection to Republican Jack Buechner. This year, Republican incumbent Ann Wagner lost reelection in this district, which represents St. Louis suburbs.

In New York, the retirement of Republican William Carney in the 1st district produced the election of Democrat George Hochbrueckner. In the 30th district, Republican Fred Eckert lost reelection to Democrat Louise Slaughter. However, in the historically Republican 34th district, the retirement of Democrat Stan Lundine to run for lieutenant governor resulted in the election of Republican Amo Houghton.

In North Carolina, Republican Bill Cobey of the 4th district lost reelection to Democrat David Price and Republican Bill Hendon lost reelection to Democrat James M. Clarke in the 11th district. Clarke had lost reelection in 1984.

In Oklahoma, Democrat James R. Jones of the Tulsa-based 1st district retired to run for the Senate, and he was succeeded by Republican Jim Inhofe. Republicans have held the district since.

In Pennsylvania, Democrat Robert Edgar of the 7th district retired to run for the Senate, being succeeded by Republican Curt Weldon.

In South Carolina, Republican Carroll Campbell of the 4th district retired to run for governor, resulting in the election of Democrat Liz J. Patterson.

In Utah, Republican David S. Monson of the 2nd district lost reelection to Democrat Wayne Owens, who had previously served in Congress from 1973 to 1975.

In Virginia, Republican G. William Whitehurst of the 2nd district retired, and Democrat Tom Pickett succeeded him. Democrats also won the 2nd district from the Republicans this year.

In the Senate, six of the losers had rode in on the Reagan wave of 1980, and credit goes to George J. Mitchell (D-Me.), head of the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee. Political scientist Norman J. Ornstein (1986) had predicted a Republican loss in the Senate based on what he called the “curse of the six-year itch”. Furthermore, unlike 2026, Democrats were dealt a much better Senate map, making 2026 all the more devastating than 1986 given Democratic wins in territory previously regarded as unwinnable, even though 1986 was bad for Senate Republicans.

In Alabama, Republican Jeremiah Denton lost reelection to Congressman Richard Shelby, who would switch to Republican in 1995. Denton, who had been elected in 1980, was the first Republican elected to the Senate from Alabama since Reconstruction.

In Florida, Republican Paula Hawkins lost reelection to Democrat Bob Graham. Hawkins, who won in 1980, had been only the second Republican elected to the Senate from Florida since Reconstruction.

In Georgia, Republican Mack Mattingly, who won in 1980, lost reelection to Congressman Wyche Fowler. Mattingly was the first Republican senator from Georgia since Reconstruction.

In Maryland, the retirement of Republican Mac Mathias, one of the party’s most prominent liberals, resulted in the election of Congresswoman Barbara Mikulski.

In Missouri, the retirement of Democrat Thomas Eagleton resulted in the election of Republican Kit Bond, one of the few bright spots for the GOP in this midterm.

In Nevada, the retirement of Republican Paul Laxalt, a close friend and ally of President Reagan, resulted in the election of Democrat Harry Reid, who would lead the Senate Democrats from 2005 to 2017.

In North Carolina, interim Republican Senator James Broyhill, who had been appointed to succeed the late John Porter East, lost the election for a full term to Democrat Terry Sanford, who had previously served as governor from 1961 to 1965.

In North Dakota, Republican Mark Andrews, first elected to the Senate in 1980, lost reelection to Democrat Kent Conrad.

In South Dakota, Republican James Abdnor, first elected to the Senate in 1980, lost reelection to Congressman Tom Daschle, who would later serve as the Senate leader for the Democrats from 1995 to 2005.

In Washington, Republican Slade Gorton, first elected to the Senate in 1980, lost reelection to Brock Adams, who had served in Congress and been Secretary of Transportation under President Carter. Rare for a defeated senator, Gorton made a comeback in 1988 and served two more terms.

The Aftermath

Although this was a solid win for the Democrats, an issue was noted right after the election from Robert Shogan (1986) of the Los Angeles Times, writing, “As the focus shifts to the 1988 presidential campaign, both parties have failed to develop the compelling national messages they need to help win the White House and govern the country afterward. Party leaders themselves conceded that such overall themes, which distinguish parties and candidates in voters’ minds and enlist their loyalties, were starkly absent this year.” The 1988 elections resulted in the victory of Vice President George H.W. Bush, and easily at that, but the House and Senate remained Democratic. However, although comebacks do happen in politics, I will say the national environment today is different; Donald Trump is no Ronald Reagan and J.D. Vance no George H.W. Bush. Yet, what we will see in 2028 will not likely bear much similarity to 2026 as people might think today. After all, the new Democratic Congress will have a record that Republicans can point to, and who knows what will happen with President Trump in the next two years.

References

Ornstein, N.J. (1986, March). The Curse of the Six-Year Itch. The Atlantic.

Retrieved from

https://www.theatlantic.com/past/politics/polibig/ornstein.htm

Ryan-Hume, J. (2023, June 7). The 1986 Midterms: The End of the Reagan Revolution? Cambridge University Press.

Retrieved from

https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/midterms-and-mandates/1986-midterms-the-end-of-the-reagan-revolution/FB50BCD2ABCE2842C02192D96BE6626F

Shogan, R. (1986, November 5). 1986: A Year of Missed Opportunity: Both Parties Fail to Present National Themes for 1988. The Los Angeles Times.

Retrieved from

https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1986-11-05-mn-15193-story.html

A Look at the Midterms

I have a certain way of going about election prognostication, and it is based on Real Clear Politics poll averages. This approach served me amazingly well when looking at the Senate elections, in which I got 100% of the predictions correct last year. I didn’t get everything right though, as I predicted a Democratic takeover of the House (they gained one seat). Although I correctly predicted that Trump would win, I did not predict that he would win Michigan and Wisconsin. I try hard to combat my personal bias in prediction and I will try to do so again this year. Let’s set some parameters of the possible in this election based on past elections:

I suspect an average Democratic bias in polls, but it won’t be as big as Republicans hope; there’s too much consistency, too much of a trend. Yes, its possible some races will flip in their favor if the Democrat is shown on average ahead by a point or two, but don’t expect a Wisconsin 2016 catastrophic polling error (Hillary Clinton was projected to win in average polling by 6.5!). That’s too ridiculous.

. Trust RCP classifications of Likely and Leans races: No Likely or Lean races have ever come out in favor of the other party.

. 5 out of 8 elections have had a net of Democratic bias in polling. Two of the three elections that had Republican bias were 2010 and 2012, the other was 2022.

. The largest margin by which a candidate was leading and the election went the other way in poll averages for the Senate was Nevada 2022.

. Leading in all late polls, although often an indicator of success, isn’t always: Russ Feingold in 2016 in Wisconsin and Chuck Cunningham in North Carolina in 2020 were leading all existing polls but the Republican kept his seat. Feingold led by 2.7 and Cunnigham led by 2.6. The most dramatic was in 2022 with Republican Adam Laxalt at 3.4 points ahead in polling, but Democrat Catherine Cortez Masto pulling the win by 0.9. The magic number here is 3.4. No Senate candidate has overcome a leading margin over 3.4 in polling. With the current polling an if this historical record sticks, this places victory out of reach for Mike Rogers in Michigan and Roger Marshall in Kansas, lest an unprecedented error occur. Dan Sullivan in Alaska, Josh Turek in Iowa, Jon Husted in Ohio, and Ken Paxton in Texas are still possible winners.

. Since 2014, average polling has been biased to the Democrats, with 2022 being the sole exception. In 2010 and 2012, the polls were biased to the Republicans. On a side note, I remain haunted by the failure of the concept of “unskewed polls” in 2012, and I have seen some strong coping energy from Republicans in the lead up to this race. However, it is also possible that the late surge in polling is similar to the 2022 surge for Republicans in the last week, which turned out to be illusory.

. There is going to be at least one upset in RCP polling averages for the Senate. It has happened every single election year! I defied this in 2022 and was wrong.

For the results, for the House, I think that Democrats get between 20-30 House seats. Those who think the House is staying Republican are frankly kidding themselves, especially given Trump’s approval rating.

My calls:

Gubernatorial Races

Florida

Byron Donalds (GOP) wins, he has consistently been ahead in polling and Florida’s fundamentals are too strong.

Georgia

Keisha Lance Bottoms (D) wins. Early voting is looking good for Democrats and she has been polling ahead recently.

Iowa

Rob Sand (D) wins, he has been leading all polls.

Kansas

Ty Masterson (GOP) wins against Democrat Cindy Holscher in the only gubernatorial pickup the GOP gets this year, and its going to be narrow. Despite a recent polling bump for Holscher I think the state’s fundamentals will work for Masterson.

Michigan

Jocelyn Benson (D) wins; John James (GOP) has not led a single poll.

Nevada

Aaron Ford (D) wins, defeating incumbent Joe Lombardo (GOP).

New Hampshire

Kelly Ayotte (GOP), who has been favored to win, wins despite recent narowing of the polls.

Ohio

Amy Acton (D) wins, she has been consistently polling ahead and Republican Vivek Ramaswamy’s ad has certainly not helped his position.

Oregon

Despite negative headwinds for her, Tina Kotek (D) wins. Oregon voters are going to think more about Trump than her this year.

Texas

Greg Abbott (GOP) wins based on the Republican fundamentals of the state; he doesn’t have the baggage of Ken Paxton.

Vermont

I get the feeling Phil Scott (GOP) does survive this one, his brand is too separate from Donald Trump’s; he endorsed Kamala Harris in 2024.

Wisconsin

David Crowley (D) wins, he has consistently led Congressman Tom Tiffany (GOP).

Senate

In Alaska, the second “Dan Sullivan” scandal and Mary Peltola’s campaign’s involvement in it gets Senator Dan Sullivan another term, just narrowly. Peltola wanted to establish that she was different from other politicians, but this scandal casts doubt on this idea. Right now I am calling this one as the one in which there is an upset in RCP poll averages.

In Florida, Senator Ashley Moody keeps her seat. Although the 2026 environment is unfavorable to Republicans, Florida is now too Republican and Democrat Angie Nixon is too radical to win the seat.

In Georgia, Senator Jon Ossoff retains his Senate seat against Trump favorite Representative Mike Collins. Collins has not led in a single poll. He’s not even in striking distance.

Congresswoman Ashley Hinson wins the Iowa Senate seat against Democrat Josh Turek narrowly. The RCP average is tied, but Iowa is still a Republican state, the state has a history of over-polling Democrats, and she doesn’t have some of the distinct negatives that the next Republican has.

Until last week, I thought Roger Marshall was going to hold on by the skin of his teeth in Kansas. I remember when Independent Greg Orman was thought to be a threat to Pat Roberts but Roberts held on by 10 points in 2014. However, 2014 was a great year for Republicans and Orman on average was only up by less than a point. 2026, however, is looking to be a rough one. Democrat Adam Hamilton appeals to a number of people as a moderate and Marshall has faced backlash not only as the top Trump surrogate in Kansas but also his frequent time spent at his second home in Florida (which he only recently sold) and he has gotten bad press for his medical practice taking legal action against a number of his patients.

Until last week, I thought Susan Collins holds on in Maine and that she’s done it before and she’ll do it again. The problem is that this race is far more frequently polled than the 2020 race in which Democrat Sara Gideon led in all polls. Indeed, this time the race is probably better examined by the pollsters and Collins no longer outpaces the partisan lean of her state.

Abdul El Sayed wins the Senate seat in Michigan…no polls as of late have shown Republican Mike Rogers as leading, and in order for him to win given the current polling, an error nearly as bad as the Hillary Clinton 2016 polling errors in Wisconsin would have to occur. This is despite an anti-Semitic ad from Cenk Uygur (which dates to 2024 funny enough) coming out on his behalf to which his response is not exactly satisfactory and Haley Stevens’ endorsement of Rogers. Most endorsements these days just don’t weigh much on the scale in the anti-establishment mood everyone’s in, with Trump endorsements in Republican primaries being a major exception.

Although Minnesota looked interesting, the state’s voters are going to overlook the fraud scandals under the Walz Administration and elect Lieutenant Governor Peggy Flanagan to the Senate. The state’s Democratic lean as well as Trump’s unpopularity is just going to keep the DFL up for now.

Although the notion of Republican John Sununu making a comeback in New Hampshire is interesting, the state’s voters are once again going to be inclined to vote Democrat for Congressman Chris Pappas. Sununu has not led or even been close in a significant poll as of late.

In Nebraska, Senator Pete Ricketts looks like he’s going to survive despite a scare from Independent Dan Osborn.

In North Carolina, Democrat Roy Cooper winning the Senate seat was and remains a foregone conclusion as he was a popular governor of the state.

In Ohio, Democrat Sherrod Brown pulls off the rare feat of a defeated senator winning back his seat. This is not only because of this year being a backlash to Trump but also because Brown has far more name recognition than Jon Husted, who as an appointee of Governor DeWine has not made much of an impression aside from being a Republican and Trump’s recent observation about his posterior. We live in interesting times!

In South Carolina, Darline Graham Nordone holds on to her brother’s seat. South Carolina is too Republican to flip, even under these ideal conditions for Democrats.

In Texas, James Talarico prevails…too many people don’t like Ken Paxton, who in my opinion is the worst choice Republicans have made in a primary in the South since they nominated Roy Moore in Alabama back in 2018. Yes, conservatives will say that Talarcio is “weird”, but I hold that Paxton’s issues likely outweigh Talarico’s among the general electorate. If I was to look at elections without thinking about party, I would consider El Sayed and Paxton to be the worst candidates this cycle, and it is entirely possible both of them win, but my money’s on El Sayed and Talarico. Flaws in Democratic candidates are just largely going to be overlooked this year because the issues of Trump and inflation are just more in the minds of the public.

In conclusion, Republicans lose the Senate, holding 48 seats, putting them in the worst position they have been in the Senate since after the 2012 election. Some things that are pretty incredible have to happen for this outcome, but with a president with around a 39% approval rating based on inflation, a war in Iran that he didn’t make the case with the American public beforehand for that is contributing to said inflation, and tariffs contributing to said inflation. The picture overall looks grim for Republicans, but my message for Republicans is…don’t let my prognostications discourage you from going to the polls…perhaps YOU can play a part in proving me wrong! And for Democrats, if you think you can defy my predictions on Alaska and Iowa or elsewhere, be my guest! By the way, I have below a history since 2014 of polling bias in RCP averages and the actual margins of victory. A positive bias is one towards the Democrats while a negative is one towards the Republicans. They are quite illuminating!

RINOs from American History #28: Connie Morella – The Last of the Liberal Maryland Republicans

In 1986, Congressman Michael Barnes of the 8th district, based in Bethesda, opted not to run for another term to run for the Democratic nomination for the Senate. The 8th has never in its history elected a conservative, but it has elected Republicans, and this time around, even though 1986 was not a good year for the GOP, Republican Constance “Connie” Morella (1931- ) won the seat by six points by winning numerous crossover Democratic votes in an upset. Voters were charmed by her outgoing and gregarious personality and furthermore she was sufficiently liberal for the district.

Morella had grown up in a Democratic working-class family and became Republican after marrying her husband, Anthony, who worked for numerous liberal Republicans, including Maryland’s Mac Mathias and New York City mayor John Lindsay. Her political career had begun when she was among the founding members of the Montgomery County Commission for Women, where she advocated for women’s rights and supported the Equal Rights Amendment. On social issues, Morella was pro-choice, anti-death penalty, pro-gun control, and pro-gay rights. She also has the distinction of being the only Republican to have voted against both the Gulf War and the Iraq War. Morella was very much a Republican in the mold of former Maryland Senator Mac Mathias, who had been a frequent Republican dissenter of both the Nixon and Reagan Administrations on both domestic and foreign policy. Speaking of, she was one of the few Republicans to vote against naming D.C.’s airport after Reagan in 1998. When asked after her career how she reconciled being a Republican in a Democratic district, she responded, “I practiced the three Cs: Country, constituency, conscience” (Fischer). She also sided with President Clinton frequently, including her support of the Family and Medical Leave Act, the Motor Voter Law, and the Brady Act as well as being one of four House Republicans to vote against all articles of impeachment of President Clinton. She was also a key figure in getting the Violence Against Women Act passed in 1994 (Fischer). However, she was not a 100% liberal; she differed with liberals in her support of NAFTA, supported a Balanced Budget Amendment, voted against the Clinton budget package in 1993 that included tax increases, and supported the Bush tax cuts. Despite her overall liberal stances, Morella had friendly relations with fellow Republicans. She recounted, “I think I had the respect of my colleagues, which is why I got away with so much (laughs), if I can put it that way! I was never nasty to them. I was always very civil. They always knew how I was going to vote” (Maddux).

Despite her district being Democratic, Morella continued to win reelection by double-digits, that is, until 2000, when she won by six points. This narrow showing encouraged the state’s Democratic leadership to target Morella’s seat for redistricting by adding territory from the Baltimore-based 4th district. Although she ran a strong campaign, she was defeated by Democrat Chris Van Hollen (who is now one of Maryland’s senators) by 4 points in 2002. Had she run in her old district, she would have narrowly won reelection. She sided with the liberal Americans for Democratic Action 68% of the time and her DW-Nominate score is -0.018. In 2003, President Bush tapped her to serve as US Permanent Representative to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, a post she served in until 2007. Morella joked on the job change, “I went from Parris Glendening [the Governor of Maryland who had helped engineer her defeat] to Paris, France” (Fischer). In 2020, Morella was among a group of former Republican representatives to endorse Democrat Joe Biden. She cited several factors in her decision: withdrawing from the Iran deal, the World Health Organization, and the Paris Climate Accord, and Trump’s personality flaws, adding, “I just think we need a change. I just don’t hold him in the highest regard with regard to integrity” (Depuyt).

References

ADA Voting Records. Americans for Democratic Action.

Retrieved from

Depuyt, B. (2020, August 24). Morella, Gilchrest Join With Ex-Congressional Republicans Backing Biden for President. Maryland Matters.

Retrieved from

https://marylandmatters.org/2020/08/24/morella-gilchrest-join-with-ex-congressional-republicans-backing-biden-for-president

Fischer, A. (2009). Morella Let Her Conscience Be Her Guide. Library of Congress.

Retrieved from

https://www.loc.gov/loc/lcib/0904/morella.html

Maddux, B. (2013, October 17). A ‘Somerville gal’s’ remarkable life. The Somerville Times.

Morella, Constance A. Voteview.

Retrieved from

https://voteview.com/person/15434/constance-a-morella

Great Conservatives from American History #33: Charles Wiggins – The Great Nixon Defender

The year 1966 constituted a backlash against the policies of the Johnson Administration, and some incumbents went down who were thought to be in good shape in their districts. Republican attorney and mayor of El Monte Charles Edward Wiggins (1927-2000) challenged incumbent Democrat Ronald B. Cameron in the 25th district in Orange County. Cameron had previously defeated Republican John Rousselot in 1962, as he had attracted great controversy for being a prominent member of the John Birch Society. However, Wiggins could not be painted in the same light, and on Election Day 1966 he ousted Cameron by 5 points. This would be Wiggins’ toughest election as he would prove popular in his district.

Wiggins on Policy

At first, it may have seemed like Wiggins was going to be an extreme conservative; in 1967 the liberal Americans for Democratic Action found him in agreement on none of the 15 votes they had tallied as most important, and this included a civil rights bill that had the support of all but 25 Republicans. However, he would prove that he had more layers than just ultra-conservative; as a member of the House Judiciary Committee he was involved in the consideration of Constitutional amendments, and he was regularly against further amendments; in 1971, he was one of 19 representatives to vote against the 18-year-old vote and one of 24 to vote against the Equal Rights Amendment, but in the same year he also voted against the School Prayer Amendment. In 1978, Wiggins voted against an amendment letting Washington D.C. elect representatives. However, this didn’t mean he was against autonomy for D.C., as in 1973 he voted for the law permitting D.C. to elect its own mayor and city council. He also wasn’t opposed to all efforts to amend the Constitution; in 1969 he voted in favor of an amendment scrapping the Electoral College. His political stances had some variance; although in 1969 he supported killing the Philadelphia Plan (affirmative action precursor) he also supported expanding the government’s ability to enforce anti-discrimination laws in 1971. Wiggins was a staunch supporter of President Nixon’s policy on Vietnam and although he was in opposition to most anti-poverty programs, he did support the creation of the Legal Services Corporation to help provide legal assistance to the poor. In 1974, he was one of 48 representatives to vote against the Federal Election Campaign Act Amendments in 1974, which provided for federal funding of presidential campaigns, limitations on campaign contributions, and the establishment of the Federal Election Commission. On economics, Wiggins supported free market approaches to policy and was in opposition to price control on gas. He was also fiscally conservative, voting to sustain the vetoes of Presidents Nixon and Ford on spending. However, Wiggins backed a few hot-button positions unpopular with rank and file conservatives, such as voting for the New York City bailout in 1975, against the Hyde Amendment in 1976, and his support for the Panama Canal Treaties. He also went against President Ford on voting to override his veto of the bill providing for national standards for strip mining in 1975. Wiggins opposed the 1975 Voting Rights Act extension and led the push for an alternative formula for coverage under the act, one more lenient than what existed, namely he called for a standard of coverage based on minority turnout rates.

Wiggins and Watergate

Wiggins was one of the three leaders of the defense of the Nixon Administration during the Watergate hearings. Their strategy, per The New York Times (2000) was “…to construe the evidence as narrowly as possible, require ironclad proof and propose benign explanations of information damaging to the president” (Pace). However, upon the release of the Watergate tapes, he changed his mind and supported impeachment, but wanted the president to resign to avoid dragging things out. Wiggins lamented where he had to stand, stating, “Such a conclusion was a sad and personally wrenching one for me to reach, because I regarded–and still do regard–myself as a friend of the president and his family and one still willing, proudly, to claim his achievements” (Nelson & Weinstein). Although Wiggins’ defense of Nixon certainly harmed his political prospects, he nonetheless prevailed in reelection in 1974, winning by 15 points. In 1978, Wiggins opted to retire to private legal practice, and he was succeeded by the much more conservative William Dannemeyer. His DW-Nominate score is a 0.359, he was in agreement with the conservative Americans for Constitutional Action 79% of the time, and in agreement with the liberal Americans for Democratic Action 15% of the time. However, he was not out of government for good.

Judge Wiggins

In 1984, President Reagan tapped Wiggins to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, and he issued some substantive rulings. In 1994, he upheld the military’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy in Holmes v. California National Guard, finding that it was not in violation of the 1st and 5th Amendments (Nelson & Weinstein) In 1996, Wiggins assumed senior status (semi-retirement for judges). In 1998, he testified before Congress during the Clinton impeachment hearings and urged a “nay” vote as he found the charges too vague (Pace). He was in poor health in his last years, suffering from diabetes and heart disease, dying on March 2, 2000 at the age of 72.

Conclusion

The inclusion of Wiggins may seem odd, but in truth on most matters he was conservative and was a man who thought for himself, unafraid to take unpopular positions, whether in opposition to consensus or his party’s preferences. I tremendously value the latter, which is why the current era of politics is disturbing to me. Pardon the late aside, but I see two political cults present in American politics: the Cult of Trump and the Cult of Social Justice, the latter which seems to be increasingly going mask off in its favorability to communism, and the former which tries very very hard to form a greater ideological philosophy from whatever President Trump wishes. The truth about President Trump is that although yes he is a man of the right, he is also temperamental and often acts based on his whims, whether for good or ill. Seeing people twist like pretzels in justification for some of the things he does (such as imposing tariffs so broad and slipshod that they included islands with penguins rather than humans as residents) is simultaneously amusing and disheartening. Choose systems and philosophies, not men, and don’t insist on 100% agreement with you as it is not realistic, and there is also a non-zero chance that you are wrong (GASP!). President Reagan was right when he said that someone who is 80% your friend and ally in politics is not 20% your enemy. Use your own brains, people! Don’t merely be a mouthpiece for others.

Bonus:

Wiggins’ press conference explaining his position on Watergate after the release of the Watergate tapes:

References

ADA Voting Records. Americans for Democratic Action.

Retrieved from

Nelson, S.S. & Weinstein,H. (2000, March 4). U.S. Judge Charles E. Wiggins; Backed Nixon During Watergate. The Los Angeles Times.

Retrieved from

https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2000-mar-04-mn-5189-story.html

Pace, E. (2000, March 8). Charles Wiggins, 72, Dies; Led Nixon’s Defense in Hearings. The New York Times.

Retrieved from

Wiggins, Charles Edward. Voteview.

Retrieved from

https://voteview.com/person/11055/charles-edward-wiggins

Trade Agreements from NAFTA Onwards – Important Votes

President Clinton signs NAFTA into law.

Given Friday’s Supreme Court ruling on tariffs and Trump’s condemnation of the decision and his move forward under different laws, it strikes me that the way the parties are regarding tariffs these days are laser-focused on what Donald Trump thinks. And neither of the directions the Democrats or the Republicans are going are ones that have been consistent with what the parities have been standing for for the past few decades. Below I am going to show you the splits on trade agreements, and you will see where the parties have been standing and to what degree:

House

North American Free Trade Agreement

Passed 234-200: D 102-156; R 132-43; 1 0-1, 11/17/93.

China Trade Normalization

Passed 237-197: R 164-57; D 73-139; I 0-1, 5/24/00.

Andean Trade Bill

Passed 215-212: R 190-27; D 25-184; I 0-1, 7/27/02.

Dominican Republic-Central America-Free Trade Agreement Implementation Act

Passed 217-215: R 202-27; D 15-188, 7/28/05.

U.S.-Oman Free Trade Agreement

Passed 221-205: R 199-28; D 22-177, 7/20/06.

U.S.-Peru Free Trade Agreement

Passed 285-132: D 109-116; R 176-16, 11//08/07.

South Korea Trade Agreement

Passed 278-151: R 219-21; R 59-130, 10/12/11.

U.S.-Colombia Trade Promotion Agreement

Passed 262-167: R 231-9; D 31-158, 10/12/11.

U.S.-Panama Trade Promotion Agreement

Passed 300-129: R 234-6; D 66-123, 10/12/11.

Trade Facilities and Trade Enforcement Act (Conference Report)

Passed 256-158: R 232-3; D 24-155, 12/11/15.

Senate

North American Free Trade Agreement

Passed 61-38: D 27-28; R 34-10, 11/20/93.

China Trade Normalization

Passed 83-15: R 46-8; D 37-7, 9/19/00.

Andean Trade Bill – Bolivia, Colombia, Ecuador, and Peru

Passed 66-30: D 25-25; R 41-5, 5/23/02.

Dominican Republic-Central America-Free Trade Agreement Implementation Act

Passed 54-45: R 43-12; D 11-33, 6/30/05.

U.S.-Oman Free Trade Agreement

Passed 60-34: R 48-5; D 12-29, 6/29/06.

U.S.-Peru Trade Agreement

Passed 77-18: D 30-17; R 47-1, 12/04/07.

South Korea Trade Agreement

Passed 83-15: D 38-14; R 45-1, 10/12/11.

U.S.-Colombia Trade Promotion Agreement

Passed 66-33: R 44-2; D 22-31, 10/12/11.

U.S.-Panama Trade Promotion Agreement

Passed 77-22: R 46-0; D 31-22, 10/12/11.

Trade Facilitation and Trade Enforcement Act (Conference Report)

Adopted 75-20: R 47-3; D 28-17, 2/11/16.

As you can see, strong majorities of Republicans have consistently favored trade agreements and Democrats have opposed them, although their margins of opposition are a bit more variable. Interestingly, the Senate tends to be more favorable to trade agreements than the House. However, part of the Trump base are people who are deeply opposed to “globalism” and part of this means trade agreements. Whether we like it or not, Trump is the center of the US political universe for the time being, and the parties’ stances on this issue are increasingly motivated by where he stands and what he is doing on trade. Most Republicans are scared to death of being primaried by someone who promises 100% loyalty to Trump, while Democrats by and large want to make showings of opposition to Trump, especially since many of their base supporters are outraged with them based on a perception that Democrats don’t do enough against him. Since Democratic base voters are a dime a dozen in my part of Washington, I’ve noticed that they don’t seem to have a real idea of what would be sufficient against him aside from immediate removal from office, but they don’t have a legal means to do it within reach (they would have to win 2/3’s of the Senate or short enough of that for a few Republican rebels to vote for conviction).

Bill Nelson: From Reagan Democrat to Establishment Democrat

Some people of a conservative mindset may ask what happened to the Democratic Party. Interestingly, there are people whose records were considerably more moderate or even conservative before the politics of the 21st century. Some would say that a lot of Democrats back then would be Republicans now. However, this doesn’t account for politicians adapting to the directions of their parties. A prominent example of this is a recent politician in Clarence William “Bill” Nelson (1942- ).

An attorney by profession, Bill Nelson got his start in politics by working as a legislative assistant to Governor Reuben Askew with his election to the state legislature in 1972. He won reelection in 1974 and 1976, and this time put him in a good position to run for Congress. In 1978, Republican Lou Frey announced that he would not run for another term. Nelson was an ideal candidate for his time and place; a man of 36 with a model American family running against a politician who although had avoided jail-time was tied to a campaign fundraising scandal in 64-year old Republican Edward Gurney. Although this Florida district had been electing Republicans since 1962, when it first elected Gurney, Democrats had a 60-40 party registration advantage (Peterson). Furthermore, Nelson was running as a conservative Democrat thus Gurney couldn’t pin the label of liberal on him. He won the election by 24 points and established a record that was moderate to moderately conservative. Nelson opposed government funding of abortion, supported the death penalty, and backed the Reagan tax cuts in 1981. However, he supported rolling them back considerably with his support of the proposed 1983 Tax Equity bill and was supportive of funding increases for domestic programs and opposed to limiting food stamps. In 1986, Nelson was the second member of Congress and the first representative to travel into space in Space Shuttle Columbia. After all, he represented Florida’s Space Coast where Cape Canaveral is located.

In 1990, he opted against running for another term for Congress to run for governor. However, Nelson had a formidable primary opponent in former Senator Lawton Chiles Jr., and miscalculated in his campaign against him when he made Chiles’ health an issue, particularly his use of Prozac to treat depression, which was made worse by his running mate suggesting that Chiles was suicidal, a suggestion Nelson disavowed (Orlando Sentinel). Running against Chiles on mental health didn’t stick to the man that Floridians had thrice elected to the Senate, and he easily prevailed.  

If his 1990 gubernatorial race was the end of his national career, I would be fine with the common view of him that he was a centrist or even a moderately conservative Democrat. From 1979 to 1984, he sided with the conservative Americans for Constitutional Action 63% of the time. However, Nelson’s career had quite a way to go and in 1994 the reelection of Governor Chiles also saw the election of Nelson as Treasurer, Insurance Commissioner, and Fire Marshal of Florida (yes, it is all one office). He won reelection in 1998, and his experience positioned him for a Senate run. In early 2000, Nelson resigned to run for the Senate, and just like the state’s presidential race, its Senate race was close and heated. His opponent was conservative Republican Congressman Bill McCollum, and both ran strongly negative campaigns against each other. Nelson repeatedly labeled his opponent as an extremist who would sacrifice the elderly, the poor, and the working class to coddle the rich while McCollum labeled him as “a liberal who would tax everything that moves, and some things that don’t” (Bragg). At the time, Nelson had the more solid case for the political center given his record in the House while McCollum had a pretty consistent conservative record. As political science professor Aubrey Jewitt noted, “he was known as a fairly moderate Democrat and right now that’s a good ideological place to be” (Bragg). Although Bush very narrowly officially won the state by 537 votes in one of the nation’s most controversial elections, Nelson edged out McCollum in the Senate election by 5 points.

Senator Nelson

It should be noted that representing a district and representing a state can be a different ballgame and some politicians indeed have shifted left from when they represented a district as opposed to a state. Prominent examples include Senator Kirsten Gillibrand of New York who as a representative of an upstate district was pro-gun rights and now is pro-gun control and even more dramatically Charles Goodell of New York who went from moderately conservative establishment Republican to staunchly liberal anti-Vietnam War Republican in the Senate in what seems to have been an unsuccessful effort to make a Republican-Liberal Party coalition run for a full term in 1970. Indeed, the contrasts between Nelson as a representative and Nelson as a senator are considerable. Although in his first term in the Senate, you could make an argument that he seemed to represent was he was selling to Floridians, and contrary to what McCollum claimed he did vote for some tax reductions, notably ending the estate tax and extending the Bush tax cuts (although he had originally opposed them). However, in his first term he nonetheless sided with the American Conservative Union (ACU) 20% of the time and liberal Americans for Democratic Action (ADA) 79% of the time. As a representative, he had agreed with the ACU 55% of the time and ADA only 34% of the time. The 2006 election gave him a green light to be a party loyalist even more as he was reelected by 22 points not only due to a poor political climate for Republicans but also due to a weak candidate in Congresswoman Katherine Harris.

In his second term, Nelson was strongly with the liberal position and a loyalist to the agenda of the Obama Administration. He even stated his support for a “public option” for healthcare in 2009, an issue of contention among Senate Democrats (Dunkelberger). Indeed, Nelson sided with ACU 8% of the time in this term. Now wait…you might say, that’s just a conservative skew! However, he also sided with ADA positions 93% of the time! Thus, again, both conservatives and liberals agreed on where he stood on the American political spectrum. One area in which he was consistent over time on the conservative position was on favorability to free trade agreements. Furthermore, with Obama winning reelection not only nationally but also in Florida in 2012, Nelson pulled off an 11-point win. Once again, Republicans had run a weak candidate, this time in Congressman Connie Mack IV. A Florida Republican operative had said about Mack, “He’s a weak candidate. Let’s just be honest. He is a pale shadow of his father’s greatness as a politician” (Miller). Nelson’s third term represented more agreement with the Obama Administration as after all, Florida voters had opted to return him to office!

His siding with ACU and ADA differed a bit in his third term: 3% for the former and 87% for the latter. I should note that it is my opinion based on what I’ve seen of their ratings that ACU under Matt Schlapp has made their grading of politicians tougher and more oriented towards the politics of Rand Paul. However, Nelson’s loyalty to the Obama Administration was noted by journalist Ledyard King (2014) when he wrote that a new analysis showed that along with 16 other Senate Democrats he “voted in line with President Barack Obama’s positions 100 percent of the time last year”. In 2018, although Nelson in theory had the benefit of a good political environment given that this was looking to be a backlash election against Trump, he undoubtedly lacked the benefit of a weak candidate. Rick Scott was reasonably popular as Florida’s two-term governor, and better yet for the Republicans they were making inroads with Hispanic voters overall and not just increasing their support among Cuban-Americans (Ogles). Furthermore, Florida was increasingly moving to Republicans and Nelson’s loyalist record to President Obama as well as his opposition to nearly all Trump policies wasn’t playing so well in Florida now. This was highlighted with his announcement before Trump picked a Supreme Court nominee in 2018 that he expected to vote against the nominee based on protecting Roe v. Wade (Smith). The issue of abortion was yet another way in which Nelson had flipped; as a representative he had had an almost entirely anti-abortion record while as a senator, he had a record almost entirely supportive of abortion rights, only voting to prohibit taking minors across State lines without parental consent for abortions in 2006. This election was so close that it was decided by just over 10,000 votes, or 0.13% of the vote, with Scott prevailing. Nelson subsequently served as the administrator of NASA from 2021 to 2025.

In his overall Senate career, Nelson sided with ACU 10% of the time and ADA 86% of the time. Both ADA and ACU found Senator Nelson’s peak year of dissent from the liberal position as 2006, when he only sided with the liberal position on 60% of the votes they considered to be most important. Over his entire career, he sided with ACU 27% of the time and ADA 65% of the time, with his DW-Nominate score standing at -0.193. While his overall record does paint him as a moderately liberal Democrat, it makes more sense to see Representative Nelson as distinct from Senator Nelson, much like it made sense to see Representative Goodell of New York as distinct from Senator Goodell of New York.

The change of Bill Nelson overtime:

References

ADA Voting Records. Americans for Democratic Action.

Retrieved from

Bragg, R. (2000, October 18). The 2000 Campaign: A Florida Race. The New York Times.

Retrieved from

https://archive.ph/20120714153120/http://select.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=FB0712FA3C5A0C7B8DDDA90994D8404482

Chiles Says Slip in Pep Got Him Back on Prozac. (1990, August 8). Orlando Sentinel.

Retrieved from

Dunkelberger, L. (2009, October 11). Nelson says he supports public option for health care. The Gainesville Sun.

Retrieved from

https://www.gainesville.com/story/news/local/2009/10/11/nelson-says-he-supports-public-option-for-health-care/31725108007/

King, L. (2014, February 9). View from the Beltway: Nelson’s votes are parallel to Obama stance. Florida Today.

Retrieved from

https://www.floridatoday.com/story/news/local/2014/02/09/view-from-the-beltway-nelsons-votes-are-parallel-to-obama-stances/5319611/

Miller, J. (2012, June 20). Rep. Connie Mack IV Still Has Uphill Battle for Senate Seat. Roll Call.

Retrieved from

https://rollcall.com/2012/06/20/rep-connie-mack-iv-still-has-uphill-battle-for-senate-seat/

Nelson, Clarence William (Bill). Voteview.

Retrieved from

https://voteview.com/person/14651/clarence-william-bill-nelson

Ogles, J. (2019, January 13). Rick Scott pollsters show strong Hispanic support helped victory. Florida Politics.

Retrieved from

Peterson, B. (1978, September 10). Florida’s Ex-Sen. Gurney Striving to Return to Congress. The Washington Post.

Retrieved from

https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1978/09/11/floridas-ex-sen-gurney-striving-to-return-to-congress/c5e22335-a52e-4634-bd54-07520df528e9/

Sen. Bill Nelson. American Conservative Union.

Retrieved from

http://ratings.conservative.org/people/N000032?year

Smith, A.C. (2018, July 2). Bill Nelson says he expects to vote against President Trump’s Supreme Court nominee. Miami Herald.

Retrieved from

https://www.miamiherald.com/news/politics-government/state-politics/article214206684.html

A Lot Changes: A Look at the Senate 40 Years in the Past

Bob Dole (R-Kan.), Senate Majority Leader

Back in 1986, Ronald Reagan is on his second term as president, having won a 49-state landslide and only narrowly losing Minnesota, the home state of his opponent, Walter Mondale. Like Trump, Reagan had the benefit of a Republican Senate although unlike Trump he never had the benefit of a Republican House. The composition of the Senate during this time presents a fascinating contrast to today. For one thing, although by this point the South is on presidents in the Republican column, it has yet to move there in its Senate composition. Today, the South’s senators are Republican save for Georgia and Virginia. In the 99th Congress, Democrats held one seat in Alabama, both of Arkansas’ seats, one of Florida’s, one of Georgia’s, both of Louisiana’s, one of Mississippi’s, one of North Carolina’s, one of South Carolina’s, both of Tennessee’s, and one of Texas’s. That’s right, in 1984 Tennessee overwhelmingly elected Al Gore to the Senate. Republicans actually hold both of Virginia’s Senate seats as back then it was a conservative state. Virginia and West Virginia have switched places since then, as both of their senators are Democrats. Another bizarre feature of this time was that Democrats held both of Nebraska’s seats! For reference, Nebraska has not voted for a Democrat for president since 1964 and its senators were among the conservative wing of the Democratic Party. Some of the social stances they held would have gotten them a quick cancellation among the base.

New England was different too, as Republicans held a seat in Connecticut, one of Maine’s, both of New Hampshire’s, one of Rhode Island’s, and one of Vermont’s. The West Coast is downright bizarre; although Democrats have held all of the West Coast states’ Senate seats since 2009, in 1985-1986 they only have California’s Alan Cranston. However, the Republicans who hold these seats would, save for Pete Wilson and perhaps Slade Gorton, be although to the right of Democrats holding these seats today, far from tolerable for the modern Republican base. In truth, 48 Senate seats are different in party affiliation between this time and now.  Kentucky at that time has freshman Senator Mitch McConnell, now in his last year of service, and the last Democrat to represent the state in the Senate in Wendell Ford. In Delaware, Joe Biden is there as a Democrat, but his colleague is Republican William Roth, who played a significant role in the crafting and passage of the Reagan tax cuts and is the Roth in the Roth IRA savings account. As hard as it may be to believe, both of Minnesota’s senators are Republican! One of them, Rudy Boschwitz, had a double-digit reelection in the same year Mondale won the state. How voters viewed the president and his party varied considerably and voters were far more willing to split their tickets than now. The states that remain the same partisan composition then as they are now are Alaska, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Massachusetts, Michigan, New Jersey, North Carolina, South Dakota, Utah, Wisconsin, and Wyoming. However, a look at the agreement rates I have put up with the senators should indicate to you that the parties were far more ideologically diverse. For instance, many of the Southern senators would not pass muster in today’s Democratic Party. One of them, John C. Stennis of Mississippi, had first been elected to the Senate in 1947! Many of the New England Republicans would not be in today’s Republican Party; Lowell Weicker of Connecticut was a bane of Reagan Republicans and later identified as an Independent and supported Democratic candidates and even Gordon Humphrey of New Hampshire, the staunch Reagan conservative of the group, has been strongly anti-Trump in recent years. Neither John Chafee of Rhode Island or Robert Stafford of Vermont would be palatable to modern Republicans. I have below senators who served in both years of the 99th Congress and included are agreement rates from the liberal Americans for Democratic Action and the conservative American Conservative Union. These are a little bit different from their official ratings; I do not count absences either way unlike ADA, I count documented legislative pairs and opinions for, and I do not double-count votes unlike ACA. Each vote is weighted equally for position agreement.

References

ADA Today, 41(1). Americans for Democratic Action.

Retrieved from

ADA Today, 42(1). Americans for Democratic Action.

Retrieved from

Federal Ratings. American Conservative Union.

Retrieved from

http://ratings.conservative.org/congress

Bill Clinton the Moderate? The Conservative? Think Again!

The popular perception of Bill Clinton during his presidency was that he was a moderate, and indeed to liberals looking back, he was that or even a conservative. Indeed, the term “New Democrat” came into being to describe Clinton’s form of Democratic politics and the politics of his supporters. One figure who was not a liberal who echoed this idea of him as a conservative of some sort was conservative David Harsanyi, who wrote, “Despite bringing some big liberal ideas, earthy debauchery and all manner of corruption to the Oval Office”, he “presided over a thriving economy, declared the era of big government over and signed more consequential conservative legislation than any president since – and perhaps, anyone before him” (BBC News). Today I intend to show why this take is wrong, and the traditional view of Clinton as a liberal, not a moderate or conservative, is the accurate one, and what’s more I will do so from the liberal perspective by using the votes selected as ideologically relevant by the liberal lobbying group Americans for Democratic Action.

Issues in which Bill Clinton was liberal included:

Support of and signing into law the Family and Medical Leave Act, the Motor-Voter Law, The Brady Bill, and the National Community and Service Act in 1993.

Support of and signing into law the Goals 2000 Educate America Act, adding funds for education grants to schools.

Opposed an amendment for school choice and reducing overall spending on education in 1994.

Opposing a Republican amendment to reduce domestic spending and protect defense from more cuts in 1994.

Supported banning “assault weapons”, supported an abortion clinic access bill, and a Montana Wilderness bill designating 1.6 million acres as protected wilderness.

Opposed the original welfare reform bill in 1995 (before signing another version in 1996 as it was close to election time), opposed Republican legislation to permit the creation of “company unions” without union presence.

Pro-choice in his record of preferred positions, including his veto of a “partial birth” abortion ban.

Opposition to proposed Balanced Budget and Tax Limitation Constitutional amendments.

Support of the Caesar Chavez Workplace Fairness Act and the admission of Washington D.C. as the state of New Columbia.

Opposed Republican efforts to end the estate tax, gift taxes, and the marriage penalty.

Supported hate crime legislation.

Supported campaign finance reform legislation.

Opposed income tax reduction.

Supported closing the “gun show” loophole in gun control laws.

Supported the Comprehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty.

Supported increasing the federal minimum wage.

Opposed the creation of education savings accounts.

Supported preferential treatment for minority-owned businesses by government in 1998.

Issues in which Bill Clinton was conservative included:

He went against ADA’s judgment in his opposition to ending funding for the superconducting super-collider project.

Clinton supported NAFTA, opposed efforts to impose steel tariffs, and supported normalizing trade relations with China.

Although his budget called for defense cuts, he opposed several additional Congressional efforts to do so, such as opposing the deletion of funds for the Trident II submarine missile, opposing cutting the Ballistic Missile Defense program, and opposing cutting funding for U.S. forces in Europe. The trade parts may be considered controversial to consider conservative today, especially in the environment of a Trump-led GOP.

Clinton’s ADA agreement rates were as follows:

Senate: 1993, 70; 1994, 100; 1995, 100; 1996, 100; 1997, 100; 1998, 90; 1999, 100; 2000, 100.  

House: 1993, 67; 1994, 64; 1995, 100; 1996, 90; 1997, 100; 1998, 100; 1999, 86; 2000, 89.

For the Senate, this translates to Clinton supporting the liberal position 56 times out of 60 that he was recorded as having a position on a vote counted by Americans for Democratic Action, while in the House he supported the liberal position 63 times out of 74. The former renders his Senate agreement rate at 93% and the latter his House agreement rate at 84%. When we combine the two, Clinton comes out supporting the liberal position 88% of the time. Not moderate, and not conservative…by liberal standards! Further backing this is Clinton’s DW-Nominate score of -0.438. Something to bear in mind, however, is that DW-Nominate scores are not as reliable for presidents as they are for members of Congress, and Clinton had a lot more selectivity in his selection of legislative issues to register an opinion on than legislators do. But, with the information we have available based on actual votes cast, Clinton comes out a liberal who makes exceptions for trade and national defense. The “New Democrat” still is supportive of unions, still supports tax increases on upper incomes, supports social liberalism, and makes an exception to what is considered liberalism in the United States here and there, primarily on trade and national defense.

References

ADA Voting Records. Americans for Democratic Action.

Retrieved from

Bill Clinton’s conservative legacy? (2014, July 7). BBC News.

Retrieved from

https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-28155578

Clinton, William Jefferson (Bill). Voteview.

Retrieved from

https://voteview.com/person/99909/william-jefferson-bill-clinton

How They Voted: The War Powers Resolution

The subject of the war powers of the president have again arisen with the Saturday U.S. raid on Caracas and the capturing of Venezuelan dictator Nicolas Maduro and his wife for trial. President Trump did not invoke the War Powers Resolution, although neither did President George H.W. Bush for his invasion of Panama in 1989-1990. The War Powers Resolution is definitely a subject of discussion, though, for this most notable event and today I am looking into the circumstances of the adoption of the War Powers Resolution.

Clement J. Zablocki (D-Wis.) and Nixon.

By 1973, the U.S. was in the process of withdrawing from Vietnam and many members of Congress were critical of how both Presidents Johnson and Nixon had used their war powers. For the latter, it was when Nixon ordered secret bombings of Cambodia without seeking Congressional consent. In the House, Clement J. Zablocki (D-Wis.), chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, introduced the War Powers Resolution. The measure had bipartisan support as well as drafting, with Paul Findley (R-Ill.) being the resolution’s main author. The resolution requires the president to notify Congress within 48 hours of military action and bars forces from remaining for more than 60 days. The first body to vote on this resolution would be the House. On July 18, 1973, they voted for 244-170 (D 171-61, R 73-109). The central architect of the resolution in the Senate was Jacob Javits (R-N.Y.), one of the most liberal members of Nixon’s party who had repeatedly been in opposition to the Nixon Administration on Vietnam. He considered the measure as “a critical departure from the past” (CQ Almanac 1973). However, the measure attracted broad support, and a key senator to come out in favor was the chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee and known conservative John C. Stennis (D-Miss.), who expressed that “It is of the utmost importance to the future of this nation that we not again slip gradually into a war that does not have the moral support and sanction of the American people” (CQ Almanac 1973). However, the measure did not have the support of another prominent figure from the South, a legal authority on the Constitution, Sam Ervin (D-N.C.). Ervin held that the measure was unconstitutional, stating, “Here is a power and a duty which the Constitution clearly imposes upon the President of the United States, to use the armed forces to protect this country against invasion. And here is a bill which says expressly that the President of the United States cannot perform his constitutional duty and cannot exercise his constitutional power to protect this country against invasion for more than 30 days without the affirmative consent of Congress” (CQ Almanac 1973). There was also a small cadre of liberals who opposed the War Powers Resolution as not being sufficiently strong. Thomas Eagleton (D-Mo.) objected to the absence of a provision disallowing the use of intelligence agencies or other actors to engage in hostilities against other nations (CQ Almanac 1973). On July 20th, the resolution was adopted 72-18 (D 50-4, R 22-14), but because it was different from the House version, the measure had to go into conference. October 10th, the equation did not change in the Senate with a vote of 75-20 (D 49-6, R 26-13, C 0-1), still a veto-proof margin. However, original passage in the House had not been veto-proof. This, however, would not remain so as President Nixon’s popularity was declining from the continuing sore on his presidency that was Watergate.

Majority Leader Tip O’Neill (D-Mass.) argued for the resolution, holding that “If the President can deal with the Arabs, and if he can deal with the Soviets, then he ought to be able and willing to deal with the U.S. Congress. That is all we ask of him” (CQ Almanac 1973). Democratic leadership was united in favor, and Republican leadership was mostly united against. The exception was Senate Minority Leader Hugh Scott (R-Penn.), thus the foremost opponent in the House was Minority Leader Gerald Ford (R-Mich.). Ford, less than a year away from being president, expressed his concerns, “We may be a long ways from being out of the woods. I am very, very concerned that the approval of this legislation over the President’s veto could affect the President’s capability to move forward from cease-fire and to achieve a permanent peace” (CQ Almanac 1973). The resolution passed on October 12th 238-122 (D 163-38, R 75-84). President Nixon, as no one doubted he would, vetoed the resolution. Further eroding Nixon’s popularity, however, between final passage and his veto of the resolution, the “Saturday Night Massacre” had occurred, in which Attorney General Elliot Richardson resigned after refusing Nixon’s order to fire special prosecutor Archibald Cox, and Deputy Attorney General William Ruckelshaus was fired after refusing to fire Cox. Solicitor General Robert Bork ultimately agreed to fire Cox.

The real battle to override the President’s veto occurred in the House, as supporters had more than enough on passage in the Senate to get the resolution through. To achieve an override, eleven opponents of the president had to be lobbied to switch their votes from “nay” to “yea”. Bella Abzug (D-N.Y.), one of the most left-wing members of Congress, had opposed, stating before the conference report that “I shall vote against this bill because it is patently unconstitutional and gives the President power he does not now have…I fear that it does exactly the opposite of what we set out to do: that is, to prevent the President, any president, from usurping the power of Congress to declare war” (CQ Almanac 1973). Speaker Carl Albert (D-Okla.) and the liberal group Americans for Democratic Action actively lobbied these legislators to switch. Their efforts were successful, as eight did so, including Abzug. The House vote of 284-135 (D 197-32, R 87-103) to override on November 7th was four votes above the threshold needed to override President Nixon’s veto.

In the Senate, with an override now inevitable, a few members switched their votes later that day: Republican Howard Baker of Tennessee and Democrats James Allen of Alabama, Harold Hughes of Iowa, and Gaylord Nelson of Wisconsin switched from “nay” to “yea” while Republicans Ted Stevens of Alaska and Henry Bellmon of Oklahoma switched from “yea” to “nay”. The vote was 75-18 (D 50-3, R 25-14, C 0-1). On a side note, the vote on the resolution as reported by Voteview has an error, as Senators Tunney (D-Calif.) and Tower (R-Tex.) have their votes swapped; Tower opposed the War Powers Resolution while Tunney supported. Overall, most of the resolution’s opponents were conservative, but there were some interesting conservative votes in favor on overriding the president’s veto, such as John Ashbrook (R-Ohio), who had run a quixotic primary campaign in 1972 to Nixon’s right, the legendary penny-pincher H.R. Gross (R-Iowa), and John Rousselot (R-Calif.), the only member of the John Birch Society in Congress at the time. In the Senate, conservative Republicans were a bit more unified against with Barry Goldwater (R-Ariz.) and Jesse Helms (R-N.C.) being among the dissenters, but you did have guys like James McClure (R-Idaho) and William Scott (R-Va.) as votes in favor. In another indication of how poorly the Nixon Administration was doing on popularity, among Southern Democrats, a key group that Nixon sought to court support, only Sam Ervin voted against overriding Nixon’s veto.  

There have been critics of this resolution, both as being too strong and too weak. Law Professor Robert F. Turner argued in a Fall 2012 journal article that the War Powers Resolution was unwise, unconstitutional, and even resulted in a reduction of American security to the point that it directly contributed to the 9/11 attacks. However, Scott R. Anderson, a fellow of the Brookings Institution, holds that although the War Powers Resolution is imperfect, it was a good undertaking that had a positive result in constraining the executive in getting the US into prolonged wars.

References

Anderson, S.R. (2023, November 9). The Underappreciated Legacy of the War Powers Resolution. Lawfare.

Retrieved from

https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-underappreciated-legacy-of-the-war-powers-resolution

Enactment of War Powers Law Over Nixon’s VETO. CQ Almanac 1973. CQ Press.

Retrieved from

https://library.cqpress.com/cqalmanac/document.php?id=cqal73-1227822#_

To Agree to the Conference Report on H.J. Res. 524, Concerning the War Powers of Congress and the President. Voteview.

Retrieved from

https://voteview.com/rollcall/RH0930382

To Agree to the Conference Report on H.J. Res. 542, to Govern the Use of the Armed Forces by the President During the Absence of a Declaration of War. Voteview.

Retrieved from

https://voteview.com/rollcall/RS0930451

To Override the President’s Veto of H.J. Res. 542, Concerning the War Powers of the Congress and the President Concerning the War Powers of the Congress and the President. Voteview.

Retrieved from

https://voteview.com/rollcall/RH0930412

To Override the President’s Veto of H.J. Res. 542, to Govern the Use of the Armed Forces by the President During the Absence of a Declaration of War. Voteview.

Retrieved from

https://voteview.com/rollcall/RS0930462

To Pass H.J. Res. 524. Voteview.

Retrieved from

https://voteview.com/rollcall/RH0930249

To Pass S. 440, a Bill to Govern the Use of the Armed Forces by the President. Voteview.

Retrieved from

https://voteview.com/rollcall/RS0930303

Turner, R.F. (2012, Fall). The War Powers Resolution at 40: Still an Unconstitutional, Unnecessary, and Unwise Fraud that Contributed Directly to the 9/11 Attacks. Case Western Reserve Journal School of Law, 45(1).

Retrieved from

The McKinley Tariff

Tariffs have been figuring strongly in recent politics thanks to President Trump’s repeated changes in course throughout the year on the imposition or removal of tariffs and certain decisions surrounding them that have been questionable at best. Trump’s policies on tariffs, although more erratic than Republicans of past, given his positive mention of William McKinley does make me think of the McKinley Tariff of 1890, which was at the time a crowning partisan achievement of the GOP and one that helped bring about swift political consequences.

The 1888 election was very close, but a great success for the Republican Party. For the first time since the Grant Administration, they had achieved unified government, and under the highly capable Speaker Thomas Brackett Reed of Maine, they sought to make the most of it. At the forefront of the agenda was the bread and butter of economic Republicanism of the time…protective tariffs. Leading this charge was the popular Representative William McKinley (R-Ohio), known as the “Napoleon of Protection” for his strong advocacy. The Republican Party was at the time strongly unified behind increasing tariffs while the Democratic Party was just as if not more strongly unified against.

A key concept introduced by this legislation was the reciprocal tariff or empowering the executive to raise tariffs on commodities after their addition to the free list to disincentivize other nations from raising their tariffs on these goods. Furthermore, Harrison persuaded the Senate to adopt a provision permitting the president to sign agreements opening foreign markets (U.S. House). These provisions would be upheld unanimously by the Supreme Court as a constitutionally permissible delegation of power in the 1892 decision Field v. Clark.

The initial version of the McKinley Tariff passed 164-142 on May 21st on a highly partisan vote as only three representatives defected: Republicans Hamilton Coleman of Louisiana and Oscar Gifford of South Dakota and Democrat Charles Gibson of Maryland. In the Senate, the bill was managed by Nelson Aldrich (R-R.I.), perhaps the foremost representative of industry in the Senate. On tariffs, in which 138 votes on the subject were held that covered numerous commodities from salt to sponges, the Senate passed the bill 40-29 on September 10th a completely partisan vote. However, there were differences between the House and Senate versions and thus the measure went to conference to resolve them. On September 27th, the House voted on the conference report, which was passed 151-81, with only Republicans Harrison Kelley of Kansas and again Coleman of Louisiana breaking with party. In the Senate, however, there was some more dissent among Republicans, with Senators Preston Plumb of Kansas, Algernon Paddock of Nebraska, and Richard Pettigrew of South Dakota voting against. In its’ final form, this law raised tariffs on average from 38% to 49.5%. Certain commodities were heavily focused on for protective tariffs like manufactured goods such as tin plates to appeal to factories in the East, while wool was jacked up to appeal to the sheep farmers of the rural West. Other tariffs, however, were removed, such as those on sugar, molasses, coffee, tea, and hides, but the president was authorized to raise them should other nations choose to impose on these goods for the United States.

Puck cartoon mocking McKinley.

Although quite the achievement for the Republican Congress, it went into effect on October 6th, less than a month before the 1890 election, and prices promptly rose in response to the tariffs. The Democratic newspaper skewered the bill, and since the benefits of the tariffs (increase in domestic worker wages and jobs) had little time to take effect while the negative side took effect promptly, this resulted in a surge of disapproval of the Republicans. Eleven days after the tariff took effect, The Cleveland Plain Dealer (1890) wrote, “The consumers are finding out that they are compelled to pay the tax, and that fact will grow daily more apparent. A gentleman walked into a hardware store a few days ago and asked to see some pocketknives. A number were placed upon the show case and prices were given. “Are these McKinley prices?” he inquired. “No,” said the clerk, “but we will be compelled to raise prices. We have been busy and have not made any change in our prices yet, but we shall soon do so.” This is only one of many occurrences of which one hears on the streets, and to offset it all there is nothing but prattle about imaginary tin plate factories and other McKinley air castles”. Such unpopularity contributed a great deal to the utter slaughter the Republicans faced in the 1890 midterms including McKinley himself losing his seat, although his loss was in good part due to unfavorable redistricting. Democrats won the popular vote by 8 points in the House, which produced a gain of 86 seats for them and Republicans sustained a 93 seat loss; they also lost seats to the newly formed Populist Party. The Indianapolis Journal (1890), contrary to The Cleveland Plain Dealer, wrote in defense of the tariffs after the election, attributing much of the unpopularity to “falsehoods” propounded about the McKinley Tariff by the “importers’ press”, for instance attributing a price increase in fruits and vegetables to tariffs without mentioning that there were crop failures that produced shortages. Although Republicans continued to be for higher tariffs, they sought to proceed more carefully in the future than they had in 1890, and McKinley would have an astounding comeback, being elected Ohio’s governor in 1891, be reelected in 1893, and then be elected president in 1896. Although a high tariff man, he would embrace the idea of reciprocal tariff reductions, and the Dingley Tariff Act of 1897, although it enacted the highest tariffs on average in American history, would contain a provision permitting the president to reduce duties by up to 20%. McKinley even came around to the idea of reciprocal trade treaties shortly before his assassination.

References

Gould, L.L. William McKinley: Domestic Affairs. UVA Miller Center.

Retrieved from

https://millercenter.org/president/mckinley/domestic-affairs

The McKinley Tariff of 1890. U.S. House of Representatives.

Retrieved from

https://history.house.gov/Historical-Highlights/1851-1900/The-McKinley-Tariff-of-1890/

The Victory of Misrepresentation. (1890, November 7). The Indianapolis Journal, 4.

Retrieved from

https://www.newspapers.com/image/321737007/

To Adopt the Report of Comm. on Conference on Bill H.R. 9416. Govtrack.

Retrieved from

https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/51-1/h414

To Agree to the Conference Report on H.R. 9416 (26 STAT. 567, 10/1/1890), a Bill Reducing the Revenue and Equalizing Duties on Imports. Govtrack.

Retrieved from

https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/51-1/s383

To Pass Bill H.R. 9416. Govtrack.

Retrieved from

https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/51-1/h184

To Pass H.R. 9416. Govtrack.

Retrieved from

https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/51-1/s364

Up Go the Prices. (1890, October 17). The Cleveland Plain Dealer, 8.

Retrieved from

https://www.newspapers.com/image/1075890829/