The Remarkable Career of John Roy Lynch

Most black politicians today are Democrats as are most black voters, but the first generation of black politicians in the United States were all Republicans from the South, their time in American politics being from Reconstruction until the last of them left Congress in 1901. One of the most notable and the last survivor among them was John Roy Lynch (1847-1939).


Born into slavery, Lynch was mixed-race, with his father, Patrick Lynch, being the lead overseer of the Tacony Plantation and his mother, Catherine White, being a mixed-race slave. Lynch died in 1849 before he could finalize plans to free his family, and he served as valet to his owner, Alfred W. Davis, who Lynch would recall as “reasonable, fair, and considerate” (U.S. House). In 1862, he was drafted into the Confederate Army for service and remained enslaved until the following year, when he was freed after the Union Army captured Natchez, Mississippi. Lynch took full advantage of his opportunities, taking every chance he could to educate himself while working in the photography business. He soon got into politics, and in 1869 Governor Adelbert Ames appointed the 22-year old a justice of the peace, becoming the second black man to hold public office in Mississippi. The following year, Lynch was elected to the State Legislature and was elected the first black Speaker of the House of any state legislative body. He followed this up with his election in 1872 to Congress, being the minimum Constitutionally required age of 25 at seating. Lynch generally voted for conservative positions on economics, but would support a few inflationary measures in his first term. As a member of Congress, he passionately argued for the Civil Rights Act of 1875, stating, “It is not social rights that we desire. We have enough of that already. What we ask for is protection in the enjoyment of public rights – rights that are or should be accorded to every citizen alike” (U.S. House). In 1874, he would be the only Republican representative to win reelection in Mississippi, prevailing with 51% of the vote.


Lynch devoted his second term to defending Reconstruction and 1876 he lost reelection to Democrat James R. Chalmers as the Democratic-controlled Mississippi State Legislature had through the power of redistricting placed him in a Democratic district. Unlike in other areas of the state, Lynch managed to prevent riots at his speeches and the opposition consisted of jeers and groans (U.S. House). Although he contested the election, the Democratic majority refused to hear the case. In 1880, Lynch ran again and although he initially lost, he again contested the election and the majority, which was Republican this time, seated him instead. He focused on economic issues in this term, attempting to aid depositors who had lost money with the failure of the Freedmen’s Savings and Trust Company and promoting tariffs. He again lost reelection in 1882, a bad year overall for Republicans, by only 600 votes. Lynch would make two unsuccessful bids to return to Congress after. His MC-Index score for his three terms was an 85%. In 1884, he was the temporary chairman of the Republican National Convention, with future President Theodore Roosevelt making the speech nominating him. Lynch subsequently served in appointed posts as well as in the army, fighting in the Spanish-American War and attaining the rank of major.

In 1911, he retired from political life and moved to Chicago the following year. He became active as a historian and countered the Dunning School of Reconstruction historical narrative with The Facts of Reconstruction in 1913, arguing that the Dunning School downplayed substantial black contributions during the Reconstruction Era. Lynch was also a frequent critic of historian James Ford Rhodes’ coverage of Reconstruction, who had written that granting suffrage to blacks during Reconstruction had been a mistake. He wrote journal articles as well as Some Historical Errors of James Ford Rhodes (1922) in response. Lynch also wrote his autobiography, appropriately titled Reminiscences of an Active Life: The Autobiography of John Roy Lynch, which would be published posthumously. He was the last surviving member of this era of black politicians, dying in Chicago on November 2, 1939. Lynch’s life had been so long that he had been born during the Mexican-American War and died two months after the start of World War II.


References

John R. Lynch: Natchez’s Reconstruction Era Icon. Historic Natchez Foundation.

Retrieved from


https://natchez.org/education/historic-natchez/john-r-lynch-dunleiths-most-famous-resident

John Roy Lynch. The Mississippi Encyclopedia.

Retrieved from

Lynch, John Roy. U.S. House of Representatives.

Retrieved from

https://history.house.gov/People/Listing/L/LYNCH,-John-Roy-(L000533)/#biography

3 thoughts on “The Remarkable Career of John Roy Lynch

  1. Awesome article as usual! I definitely think that John R. Lynch deserves far more recognition than he currently gets, having actively countered the racist revisionism of the Dunning School. Also, I did not previously know that his voting record in Congress was quite conservative. Conventional narratives nowadays about Reconstruction frequently insinuate that pro-civil rights Republicans were supposedly liberal/left-wing, and that the racist Democrats were supposedly conservative. Now, although the Bourbons (which would include the Southern “Redeemers”) were financially/fiscally conservative in some respects (backing sound money), they also took some more liberal positions like favoring lower tariffs and civil service reform.

    In addition, would you know about Lynch’s stances on civil service reform? From what I’ve picked up in my research into the Stalwarts vs. Half-Breeds, it appears that the freedmen and carpetbaggers in the South utilized patronage effectively, and in 1880 were active supporters of a third non-consecutive term for Ulysses S. Grant after being disenchanted with Hayes’ conciliatory tones towards Southern Democrats. Allan Peskin divulges into some fascinating details in “Who Were the Stalwarts? Who Were Their Rivals? Republican Factions in the Gilded Age,” but doesn’t seem to list many specific members aside from faction leaders. Also, it’s stated in “Reconstruction: America’s Unfinished Revolution” that civil service reform appealed very little to blacks in part because it would prevent them from public office. (Foner, p. 507)

  2. Thank you! Your suspicions are probably right on Lynch with civil service and that rationale for them supporting patronage makes sense. The major civil service vote I see in his time is the Pendleton Act and a Democratic vote to recommit to make it stronger, both of which he was absent for and gave no indication as to his position. Lynch’s DW-Nominate score is also a 0.438, which places him well in conservative territory. The only real basis they are thinking of here for left-wing is on race relations, with “right” or “conservative” in this case meaning as close as possible to antebellum minus slavery. Classifying racial issues on a left/right scale only seems to function post-World War II.

    1. A while ago I’ve started trying to find more information about the seven House Republicans who voted against the Pendleton Act; while most of them are comparably obscure and don’t have much written about them, I did pick up a bit about Robert Smalls’ vote. The last footnote for this article on the U.S. House website (https://history.house.gov/Exhibitions-and-Publications/BAIC/Historical-Essays/Temporary-Farewell/Pre-Congressional/ ) mentions this and indicates that black congressmen of the era made the most of patronage powers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s